On the Validity of the Regulative Principle

A Response to Dr. Picirilli

I want to thank Dr. Picirilli for his response to my initial article on the Regulative Principle of Worship (RPW hereafter). I’ve benefited from his wisdom on many topics over the years, so I’m eager to continue the dialogue here.

Introduction

In my prior article I sought to (1) define the RPW, and (2) defend it against a charge often leveled against it—that it curtails the freedom of worshippers.

Dr. Picirilli’s concerns about the RPW give me opportunity to expand on the subject by responding to him, while also adding some additional definition and texture to how I think the RPW has been understood (and is still understood) by many modern-day advocates.

I understand Dr. Picirilli’s objections or concerns to relate to the proper scope or extent of the RPW, the helpfulness, practicality, or applicability of the RPW, and the origins of the RPW insomuch that it may be deemed relevant to modern Free Will Baptists. I will respond to each of these.

The Proper Scope or Extent of the RPW

First, Dr.…